5% Voter Issue (CSM)

From sdeevelopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

All this data is potentially out of date, and should be taken with a truckload of salt

Stats[edit]

  • Title: 5% Voter Issue
  • Raised by: Inanna Zuni
  • Submission Date: 09 June 2008
  • Issue ID: 0010

Summary[edit]

  1. The 5% rule as required by CCP is based on the full number of current accounts of EVE players and bears no relation to the number actually actively involved in either the debates of the CSM or in the EVE forums generally. It should be changed to some other value, preferably calculated as a percentage of those who actually voted in each election.
  2. The 5% rule for pilots to force the CSM to bring up an issue was set as a percentage of *accounts* whereas posting on the EVE forums is by *pilot name*. The two are not directly convertible by the CSM and would require CCP to validate the list of pilots who had supported a topic here and how many accounts they represented (clearly it is always fewer, but no idea by how much). As such the 5% percentage is impossible to police at this time unless an 'out of game' interface is created (very unlikely)

Potential Solution[edit]

Change the 5% of accounts to the alternate calculation decided upon at the meeting.

Pros[edit]

  • Not an insurmountable target


Cons[edit]

  • • Reduces number of votes required to force an issue to discussion

Relevant Forum Threads[edit]

Votes[edit]

  • Ankhesentapemkah - Y
  • LaVista Vista - Y
  • Bane Glorious - N
  • Serenity Steele - Y
  • Darius JOHNSON - Y
  • Dierdra Vaal - Y
  • Hardin - Y
  • Inanna Zuni- Y
  • Jade Constantine - Y